Monday, November 11, 2019
Compare how the two television programmes Essay
This is an attempt on her part to appear up-to-date, with ââ¬Å"Hollywood speakâ⬠, but is also a way for her to patronise Saffy and is symbolic of their relationship. ââ¬Å"Gimme Gimme Gimmeâ⬠is centered around a heterosexual woman and a homosexual man, with the contrast between them being the key element of the show, The humour here is much more direct than that of ââ¬Å"Absolutely Fabulousâ⬠, with great emphasis on sexual innuendos and crude elements. ââ¬Å"Gimme Gimme Gimmeâ⬠transgresses boundaries, with the two protagonists (Linda and Tom) subverting traditional gender roles. They resemble a married couple, but in reverse ââ¬â Linda is masculine, while Tom is effeminate. Tom is middle-class and cultured, and sees Linda as beneath him ââ¬â in the ââ¬ËMillennium Specialââ¬â¢, he describes her as ââ¬Ëfrighteningly working class. ââ¬Ë He is also houseproud, as shown by his Christmas punch and his dismay when Linda broke the decorations (ââ¬ËWhatever happened to Timothy tree? ââ¬Ë) He gives the impression of intelligence and often loses patience with Linda, also finding her crude humour too much on occasion: ââ¬ËYou know, sometimes you make me physically sick. ââ¬Ë In contrast, Linda is very masculine and uncultured, loud and direct, yet also childlike and nai ve. She is plainly of low intelligence and enjoys insulting Tom ââ¬â ââ¬ËI ainââ¬â¢t homophobic, I just canââ¬â¢t stand ââ¬â¢em. ââ¬Ë She frequently calls him ââ¬Ëhomoââ¬â¢, but in reality this is probably a term of endearment. Although she pretends to despise him, Linda and Tom are dependant on each other, as shown by the scene where Linda is about to go out and Tom clings to her. Lindaââ¬â¢s naiveti Regarding her father is a point of humour as in her eyes he can still do no wrong. Her words ââ¬ËDaddy wouldnââ¬â¢t lie to me! ââ¬Ë bring to mind a small child. Tom frequently uses abbreviations such as ââ¬Ëridicââ¬â¢ and ââ¬Ëphenomââ¬â¢, which adds to his camp image, and strengthens the audienceââ¬â¢s perception of him as a stereotypical gay man. Lindaââ¬â¢s character, as well as contrasting with Tom, also has elements of contrast within herself: her surname (LaHughes), suggests a far more upmarket woman than she is, and the way in which she dresses is at odds with her naiveti. ââ¬Å"Gimme Gimme Gimmeâ⬠has strong elements of sexual frustration in both characters , although Tom desires a long-term relationship and domesticity, and Linda simply wants a man. Both the house in ââ¬Å"Absolutely Fabulousâ⬠and the flat from ââ¬Å"Gimme Gimme Gimmeâ⬠are not domesticated, but for different reasons ââ¬â Patsy and Eddie are always out at work or parties, but Tom and Linda are always at home simply because they have nowhere else to go: ââ¬Å"Phone a bloody friend? What if you havenââ¬â¢t got any friends? â⬠intertextuality is present in both comedies ââ¬â from the obvious in ââ¬Å"Gimme Gimme Gimmeâ⬠(Linda and Tomââ¬â¢s discussion of ââ¬Å"Who Wants To Be A Millionnaireâ⬠and her referral to the Royle Family as ââ¬Ënorthern poncesââ¬â¢), to the more subtle use of Western music in ââ¬Å"Absolutely Fabulous. â⬠Both programmes involve dysfunctional parent-child relationships, although there is a difference in that Lindaââ¬â¢s relationship with her father is off-screen, and Saffy and Edinaââ¬â¢s is very much on-screen. Both also have ââ¬Ëchildrenââ¬â¢ in ââ¬â Eddie is a wild teenager and Linda is a spoilt younger child. Masculine women are present in both, in the form of Patsy and Linda, although both are masculine in different ways and take on different roles. The use of flashbacks in two episodes (ââ¬Å"Small Openingâ⬠and ââ¬Å"Millennium Specialâ⬠) sum up the attitudes of the two programmes ââ¬â ââ¬Å"Gimme Gimme Gimmeâ⬠ââ¬Ës shows how the protagonists want life to be, and the show is based upon them wanting better lives. The flashback in ââ¬Å"Absolutely Fabulousâ⬠shows how life sued to be, and the characters here are living in the past. A key difference is that Eddie and Patsy truly believe they are in control of their lives and are happy, whereas Linda and Tom are perfectly aware of the fact that they are going nowhere. While ââ¬Å"Absolutely Fabulousâ⬠is a satire, there is also a fantasy element about Patsy and Eddieââ¬â¢s uninhibited, hedonistic lifestyles. Both showsââ¬â¢ characters are representative types of society, and there is an absence of men in both ââ¬â the main theme of both shows. However, in ââ¬Å"Absoultely Fabulousâ⬠this is shown to be a positive thing and Patsy and Ednia show no need for them, however ââ¬Å"Gimme Gimme Gimmeâ⬠is about its protagonistsââ¬â¢ loneliness, and is centered around their quest for men (hence the title. ) ââ¬Å"Gimme Gimme Gimmeâ⬠ââ¬Ës comic representation of gender is based upon stereotypes, role reversal and class contrast, whereas ââ¬Å"Absoultely Fabulousâ⬠plays on the common idea of how a mother should be, the traditional values they have and womenââ¬â¢s independence. Both shows use subversion of roles to great effect in their comic representation of gender.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.